Der Dutchman 445 S. Jefferson Street Route 42 Plain City, OH  43064 Phone: (614) 873-3414 Fax: (614) 873-3478   Visit our website: www.DHGroup.com

Hearty helpings of Amish Kitchen Cooking.  We feature a full menu as well as full service on and offsite catering. 

MENU

BREAKFAST

Breakfast Buffet | Dutchman Favorites | Eggs & Toast | Omelettes | Hotcakes
Breads & Pastries | Fruit & Cereal | Side Orders | Children's Breakfast | Beverages
 

LUNCH & DINNER

Soups & Salads | Sandwiches & More | Something Different | Chicken | Turkey
Beef |  Pork | Fish | Sampler | Family-Style | Side Dishes | Beverages  | Desserts

BREAKFAST

Consumption of raw or under cooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish,

eggs, or milk may increase your risk of food borne illness.

Egg Beaters available additional .30 per egg.

Light Syrup available.

No substitutions please.  Each individual item will be charged ala carte.

Breakfast Buffet

Served 7:30am to 11am Monday through Saturday

All You Can Eat Breakfast Buffet

Includes scrambled eggs, bacon, sausage, fried cornmeal mush, sausage gravy, biscuits, hash browns, pancakes, fresh pastries, fresh fruit and fruit slush.

Adults    6.69    Children 6-10     3.99      Children 5 and under     2.99

Dutchman Favorites

French Toast

Made with slices of our homemade bread and served with warm syrup.

One piece    1.89             Two pieces    2.99           Three pieces    3.49

With ham, bacon or sausage add     1.59

With one egg add    .89

Cornmeal Mush

Crispy, golden slices of fried cornmeal mush served with warm syrup.

One piece    1.59            Two pieces    2.69            Three pieces    3.29

With cup of sausage gravy add    1.19

With bowl of sausage gravy add    1.89

With ham, bacon or sausage add    1.59

With 1 egg add    .89

Healthy Start

Country style turkey sausage, Egg Beaters, fresh fruit cup, and toast    6.19

Amish Scramble

Hash browns, choice of meat & two eggs all scrambled together; served with toast    5.89

With mushrooms, onions, peppers, tomatoes or cheese add    .29 each

Farmers Breakfast

Your choice chopped sirloin or country ham served with two eggs, hash browns, and toast     8.39

Biscuits & Gravy

Creamy, homemade sausage gravy ladled over fresh-baked biscuits

One biscuit    2.59        Two biscuits      3.49

With hash browns add   1.29

With one egg add   .89

Hash Browns & Gravy

Creamy, homemade sausage gravy ladled over hash browns

Half order    2.19      Full order    3.09

Der Dutchman Special

Two eggs (any style), hash browns, homemade toast, ham, bacon, or sausage with choice of a beverage.    6.39

Eggs & Toast

Served any style with homemade toast

One Egg    2.69        Two Eggs     3.29

With hash browns add    1.29

With ham, bacon, or sausage add    1.59

Add one egg     .89

Egg Sandwich    3.29

With cheese, served on toast.  With ham, bacon, or sausage add .99

Omelettes

Served with homemade toast

Cheese Omelette    4.69

To mix in ham, bacon, or sausage add    .69

Western Omelette   

Ham, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, and cheese     5.89

Vegetarian Omelette

Onions, green peppers, mushrooms, and tomato.    5.69

To mix in mushroom, onions, peppers, tomatoes or cheese add   .29 each

With hash browns add     1.29

Hotcakes

Buttermilk

One    1.89      Two    3.19

Whole Wheat

One    2.09      Two    3.49

With blueberries or chocolate chips add   .39

With Pecans add   .89

With ham, bacon, or sausage add   1.59

With one egg add    .89

Breads & Pastries

Just baked. Just delicious.

Toast

White, whole wheat, raisin, rye, sourdough, English muffin toast    1.09

Iced raisin toast    1.19

Biscuits

Two biscuits served with jelly    1.39

Cinnamon Roll    1.69

Pecan Roll    1.89

Doughnuts

Cake, sugared or glazed    .99

Apple fritters, cinnamon buns, jelly-filled, long-johns, twists or cruller    1.29

Muffin

Bran, blueberry, lemon poppyseed, pumpkin or cranberry    1.29

Although not made in our bakery, we also offer:

Bagel   

Plain, raisin or blueberry with cream cheese     1.49

English Muffin    1.39

Fruit & Cereal

Hot Oatmeal or Cream of Wheat

Served with milk and brown sugar    2.59

With raisins add    .10

With homemade toast add   .50

With homemade muffin add   .80

Cold Cereal    1.99

Homemade Granola

Cup    1.89       Bowl    2.39

Fruit Cup

Cup    2.09      Bowl    3.19

Side Orders

Egg    1.69

Ham, Bacon, or Sausage    2.29

Turkey Sausage    2.59

Country Ham     3.99

Chopped Sirloin    3.29

Sausage or Tomato Gravy

Cup    1.59      Bowl    2.39

Hash Browns    1.69

With mushrooms, onions, or peppers add   .29 each

Children’s Breakfast

Children 10 and under

One Egg & Toast

Served with 2 pieces bacon or 1 sausage patty     2.49

One Hotcake

Served with 2 pieces bacon or 1 sausage patty     2.39

One Egg & Hotcake    2.39

One Slice French Toast   

Served with 2 pieces bacon or 1 sausage patty    2.39

LUNCH & DINNER

Soups & Salads
 

Homemade Soup   

Vegetable Beef, Chicken Noodle, Chili (Sept-May)     Cup 2.29      Bowl 3.19

Bowl of Soup & Salad Bar      7.19

Baked Potato & Salad Bar     
Top your potato at our salad bar.      7.19

Salad Bar      6.79

Chef Salad    

Choice of chicken, ham, beef or turkey    Small 5.19      Large 6.59

Char-broiled Chicken Breast Salad   7.89

Caesar Salad 
Served with char-broiled chicken breast     7.79

Mandarin Chicken Salad
Grilled marinated chicken breast with water chestnuts, crispy Chinese noodles, mandarin oranges, tomato and mushrooms on a green salad with sesame ginger dressing.      8.19  

Salad Dressings:

House, Thousand Island, Bleu Cheese, French, Honey Mustard, Fat-Free Ranch and  Italian.

SANDWICHES & MORE
Sandwiches on homemade bread and buns

With cup of soup or French fries add 1.79
With salad bar add 3.59
With slice of American, Swiss or Cheddar cheese add .30
 

Grilled Cheese  
American or Swiss    3.29    with ham, add .90

Hamburger  
Char-broiled, served on a bun     3.99
 

Dutchman Burger
5oz chopped sirloin with Swiss cheese     4.99

Cheeseburger  
Char-broiled, your choice of American or Swiss     4.19

Chicken Breast  
Marinated and char-broiled     4.99

Meatloaf
Homemade and served on a grilled bun     4.69

Fish  
Deep-fried cod with light breading     3.99

Roast Beef, Pork, Turkey or BBQ Beef  
Served on a grilled bun    4.09

Reuben  
Corn beef, sauerkraut and Swiss cheese on rye with Thousand Island dressing     4.39

Trail Bologna
Lightly seasoned, served hot or cold 3.89

Manhattan  
Hot sandwich served with mashed potatoes and covered with gravy. Choice of roast beef, turkey, pork or meatloaf.      7.19    Half Order    6.29
 

SOMETHING DIFFERENT

Chicken Stir Fry
Char-broiled chicken with sautéed vegetables (onions, carrots, mushrooms, broccoli & green peppers) served over rice with your choice of teriyaki glaze, ranch
dressing or honey mustard sauce.     8.29

Noodles Over Mashed Potatoes

Full Order  6.49      Half Order 5.19     With side dish, add 2.19

Want a Lighter Meal? 
Chopped sirloin or boneless breast of chicken, served with cottage cheese and fruit. No substitutions, please.     7.29

 
Vegetable Plate
Any three side dishes and a tossed salad.      6.99
 

CHICKEN

Dinners include homemade dinner rolls and your choice of two side dishes. Salad bar may be a side dish with dinners.
 

Broasted or Baked Chicken
A Der Dutchman Specialty! We serve Real Amish Farm Country Chicken. This chicken was fed a vegetarian diet with no sub-therapeutic antibiotics, no animal by-products, no growth stimulants and no added hormones. Broasted chicken is marinated, breaded and broasted under pressure—crispy outside and juicy inside. Baked chicken is seasoned, pan-fried and then baked until tender.

3 Pieces Assorted: breast, thigh, drumstick     9.29

3 Pieces, Dark: two thighs, one drumstick     8.99
2 Pieces, White: two breasts     10.19
2 Pieces, Dark: one thigh, one drumstick     8.69
2 Pieces, Assorted: one breast, one drumstick     8.99
1 Breast     8.49
Wing Dinner: five broasted wings     7.99

Char-broiled Chicken Breast
Boneless, marinated in our own special seasoning
5oz   8.99      10oz   10.19
 

TURKEY

Dinners include homemade dinner rolls and your choice of two side dishes. Salad bar may be a side dish with dinners.
 

Roast Turkey
Old-fashioned slow-roasted.    9.59    

For all white meat, add   1.69
 

BEEF
We serve only Certified Angus Beef® brand.

Dinners include homemade dinner rolls and your choice of two side dishes.  Salad bar may be a side dish with dinners.

Roast Beef 
Amish-style slow-roasted in its own juices     9.99
 

Meatloaf
An Amish-style recipe, freshly baked     8.99

Swiss Steak
Pan-fried and baked in gravy     9.99

Chopped Sirloin Steak
Delicately seasoned and char-broiled     5oz     8.49      10oz     9.99

Country Fried Steak
Breaded and deep-fried with white pepper gravy     8.89
 

Liver & Onions
Grilled liver topped with sautéed onions     4oz     7.69      8oz     8.69
 

PORK

Dinners include homemade dinner rolls and your choice of two side dishes.  Salad bar may be a side dish with dinners.

Country Cured Ham
Old-fashioned smoked ham     10.29

Grilled Ham
Thick slice of cured ham     9.29

Pork Chops

Fresh center-cut, char-broiled    One Chop     9.19     Two Chops     10.29

Roast Pork
Slow-cooked in our own seasonings     9.19
 

FISH

Dinners include homemade dinner rolls and your choice of two side dishes.  Salad bar may be a side dish with dinners.

Salmon 
6-8 oz fillet, broiled tender    11.79

Tilapia 
A fillet broiled with our seasoning    One Piece     9.89     Two Pieces     11.19
 

Grouper
6-8oz fillet, broiled or hand-breaded and deep-fried     11.49

Shrimp
Eight pieces breaded and deep-fried     10.49

Cod
Mild cod deep-fried with crispy breading     4oz     8.89     8oz     9.99

Seafood Platter
4oz. cod and 5 pieces of shrimp      10.49

AMISH COUNTRY SAMPLER

Amish Country Sampler
Sample our most popular foods. Choose any two meats:

broasted or baked chicken, turkey, all white $1.50 extra, ham, or roast beef.

Includes mashed potatoes, dressing, vegetable and salad bar.  No substitutions please     10.79

FAMILY-STYLE

“Pass the potatoes!”  You could say Der Dutchman serves Thanksgiving dinner all year
long.  Enjoy Amish-style foods served around the table the old-fashioned family way.
 

Family-style dinner includes real mashed potatoes, dressing, gravy, corn or green beans, salad bar, homemade bread, one beverage and a piece of pie.  We ask that all guests at your table order family-style.  Eat all you want, but no leftovers to take home.

Choose between broasted chicken, ham, roast beef and turkey.  Price is per person.

Chicken only    12.79

Any two meats    13.99

Any three meats    14.89
All white meat for chicken and turkey is 1.99 extra.

Children ages 3-5    4.99    ages 6-10    6.49.

Gratuity not included.

SIDE DISHES

Note: Salad bar may be a side dish with a dinner unless you are sharing a meal.
No discount for omitting side dishes.

Homemade Noodles      2.49

Homemade Dressing (Stuffing) and Gravy     2.49

Chicken Rice Pilaf     2.49

Real Mashed Potatoes and Gravy     2.49  

Baked Potato     2.49

Amish Potato Cakes     2.49

Hash Browns      2.49

French Fries     2.49

Onion Rings     2.99

Baked Sweet Potato     2.99

Sweet Potato Fries     2.99

Green Beans     2.49

Creamed Corn     2.49

Stewed Tomatoes     2.49

Steamed Mixed Vegetables with cheese sauce     2.49

Cole Slaw     2.49

Tossed Salad     2.49

Cottage Cheese     2.49

Applesauce     2.49

Jell-O     2.14

BEVERAGES

Soda
Pepsi, Caffeine Free Diet Pepsi, Root Beer, Sierra Mist, Mountain Dew, Diet Mountain Dew, Dr. Pepper (free refills)      1.69
 

Cold Drinks

Iced Tea, Sweet Iced Tea, Raspberry Iced Tea, Fruitworks 5% fruit juice (free refills)

1.69

Juice

Orange, apple, tomato, grapefruit, grape, lemonade    

Small     1.39        Large     2.29

Milk

White, buttermilk, chocolate      small 1.29       large     1.79

Fresh Ground Coffee

Superior® Whole Bean regular and decaffeinated      1.19

Hot Tea, Hot Chocolate      1.49
 

Cappuccino     1.69
 

Bottled Water     1.19

Flavored Bottled Water     
Lemon, strawberry, raspberry, orange     1.29
 

DESSERTS

All desserts are homemade in our bakery.
 

Fruit Pie:

Apple, Dutch Apple, Blueberry, Cherry, Blackberry, Peach, Raisin.

Slice of Pie       2.89    With ice cream    add .89

No sugar added:
Apple, Cherry, Pineapple.

Slice of Pie       2.89    With ice cream    add .89

Cream Pie:

Black Raspberry, Banana, Peanut Butter, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Chocolate, Coconut, Butterscotch

Slice of Pie       2.89    With ice cream    add .89

Other Favorites:

Pumpkin, Custard, Sugar Cream, German Chocolate, Lemon Meringue

Slice of Pie       2.89    With ice cream    add .89

Premium Pies

Pecan, Black Raspberry           3.19     With ice cream     add .89

Date Nut Pudding     2.89    With ice cream     add .89

 
Angel Food Cake     2.69     With ice cream or choice of topping    add .89
 

Bread Pudding     2.59    

Brownie Dessert     3.69     

Chocolate Chip Cookie   .59
 
Ice Cream

Homemade vanilla, chocolate     2.49

Sundae

Hot fudge, strawberry, caramel, chocolate     2.99

Banana Split     3.89

Milkshake     2.69

You’ll find homemade fudge in our bakery!
 

All information is deemed to be accurate but is not warranted. Prices and/or Menus are subject to change without notice. Information related to restaurants is provided solely for informational purposes only and is not an endorsement or guarantee by MenusAndMoreColumbus.com of any listed restaurant.